I love spooky stories. Some of my very favorite authors write the best ones (I'm looking at you, King and Gaiman). I am also a skeptic. I read supposedly "real" accounts of ghosts and spirits and the like and I am completely unmoved. But a fictional ghost story gets me every time.
One year later, Sylvie is trying to deal with her grief over her parents' deaths, and to process her feelings about her own role in the events of that winter's evening. She feels as though there is something important she is not remembering about what happened in that church, and she desperately wants to remember before the man accused of killing her mother and father go on trial. Her sister, who is now her guardian, is no help, all anger and indifference and sarcasm. And, the spooky events that used to plague her family during her parents' work have started happening again-dolls that appear where they shouldn't, lights that appear to turn on and off by themselves. It's all too much, and Sylvie feels as though she will go crazy if she can't discover the truth.
I really enjoyed the mood of the whole book, up until the very end. There is just enough creepy goodness to make you a little uncomfortable (in a good way, if you like that sort of thing) while you are reading (probably with the lights on). But this is also a story about mothers and daughters, about faith vs. skepticism, and about trying to do right by people, even when you're not sure what "right" is. That said, I was disappointed in the ending. Without giving anything away, I can confidently say that most readers of this book will be completely blindsided by the answer to the riddle of what happened that night in the church, not because Searle expertly crafts such a tight narrative that the clues are only obvious in hindsight, but because the clues are not really there to begin with. While this isn't technically the right term for what I mean, the resolution to the story had a deus ex machina kind of feeling. Something comes right out of left field that no one could have seen coming, which annoyed me on a certain level because it made the end feel disjointed, like the ending to another story. Or maybe I was just not paying enough attention (but I don't think so). At any rate, I'd still recommend this book to anyone who likes a good scary story, or a good family story, or a good mystery story. It's a (mostly) satisfying read.
5 Most Popular Books of the Month: April, 2017
8 hours ago