Monster, by Walter Dean Myers

Friday, June 25, 2010

I heard a disturbing statistic today-the United States has the fastest growing prison population in the world.  Not just in the western world, but the world-period!  That means that totalitarian governments like North Korea and Iran put fewer people in jail than we do.  Much of this can be traced back to mandatory sentencing for drug crimes-and while I have many opinions on that, it doesn't have much to do with the review I am about to write.  What does is another disturbing trend-more and more states are allowing youth as young as 15 to be tried as adults for violent or drug-related crimes. 

Walter Dean Myers takes this issue on in his book, MonsterMonster is the story of Steve Harmon, a 16 year-old black teenager living in Harlem.  At the opening of the book Steve is incarcerated, about to stand trial for felony murder, a charge that could carry the death penalty.  We quickly learn a few things about Steve-he's smart, he's creative, and he's terrified.  The only way he can deal with the emotions brought on by his incarceration and trial are to treat them as a screenplay.  This budding film maker may or may not have been involved in a drugstore robbery, a robbery that went horribly wrong when the store owner was shot and killed.  Steve's supposed part in the robbery-look out.  The book follows his trial, and the effect that it has on him and his family.

Most of Myers' books take on issues of race, racism, and growing up black and male in our society.  One of his strengths is that he does not make excuses for poor choices.  What he does is paint a pretty stark picture of what it can be like to grow up black, male, and poor in America.  You may not always like his characters, but you can understand their lives and their choices based on the circumstances in which they live.  Monster is no different.  It would be easy to make this story about racist police and racist judges sending another black boy to prison, but the story is more nuanced than that.  Not that there aren't elements of race and racism woven into the narrative-it is impossible to separate that strand of American culture from the rest when talking about issues of poverty, crime, and justice in America's urban centers.  But the book is not about racism, per se.  It is about one boy, coming to terms with what it would mean if he spent the rest of this life behind bars.

To me, that is the real issue that this book raises.  How can we, as a society, support sending teenagers as young as 15 and 16 to jail for the rest of their lives?  We must believe that teenagers have not yet reached the age of responsibility, seeing as we don't let children that young vote, drink alcohol, smoke tobacco, or make their own medical decisions.  How then can we expect them to pay for the rest of their lives for a decision made before rationality, reason, and responsibility have truly taken hold of their minds?   I don't have the answer for how to rehabilitate young offenders, so I won't pretend that I do, but it seems to me that before we start locking children up for what could amount to 60 or 70 years (provided the violence in prison doesn't kill them sooner, but that is another post for another blog), we should at least make sure that we have exhausted every other possibility. 


  1. As a criminal defense solicitor I couldn't agree more with your sentiments. People generally have no idea the real motivation behind most crime. Poverty. Destitution. These people have usually been abused for most of their lives, the government has failed to help them and they have turned to crime.

    Most of them (the vast majority) have serious mental health problems).

    Gaol is not the solution in a lot of cases. In a lot of cases it does more than harm than good.

    Sadly in NSW (Australia) the state government has just passed a bill that abolishes periodic detention (gaol on the weekend), a sentence that most of the younger adults (18 - 24) get when they have a minimal record but have done something pretty bad. This will only mean an increase in the numbers going into gaol full time. It's horrible.

    Sorry or the rant. Ill stop now. The book sounds great!

  2. Sounds like an interesting book and I agree with what you've written.

    Here in Toronto we have a young man running for mayor. He spent a year in jail for making a stupid choice and being involved in a robbery as a teenage. After he got out of prison, he decided to turn his life around - he became President of the student union of the largest university in Canada, became a lawyer and is now running for mayor. People can turn their lives around.

    Unfortunately I live in a neighbourhood where a lot of young men in similar situations will never change. They need books like these.

  3. Just commenting in response to what Becky wrote above--the part that sticks in my mind is "jail on the weekend"--I've never heard of that idea but I think it is a really, really smart one! Sounds far better than simple probation, and less harsh than jail full-time. I'm willing to bet that the weekend is when the most kids get into the most trouble. I suppose there would be many logistical difficulties, but I think this would be something to look into.

  4. very good book reading it now


Penny for your thoughts...