Literary Blog Hop-Contemporary Classics?

Friday, November 26, 2010

Literary Blog HopWelcome, literary hoppers!  I'm excited to participate in the Literary Blog Hop hosted by The Blue Bookcase this week, since I am not working and actually have time to string together coherent thoughts in the Question of the Week.  More on that in a moment.  And now for a word from our sponsor:

This blog hop is open to blogs that primarily feature book reviews of literary fiction, classic literature, and general literary discussion.
How do I know if my blog qualifies as "literary"? Literature has many definitions, but for our purposes your blog qualifies as "literary" if it focuses primarily on texts with aesthetic merit. In other words, texts that show quality not only in narrative but also in the effect of their language and structure. YA literature may fit into this category, but if your blog focuses primarily on non-literary YA, fantasy, romance, paranormal romance, or chick lit, you may prefer to join the blog hop at Crazy-for-books that is open to book blogs of all genres.

Now, on to the main event...can a contemporary novel be considered a classic?  Not that I want to necessarily align myself with the Catholic Church, but I think that a novel can only be called a classic once its merits have stood up against scrutiny and it's been thoroughly vetted by readers over a rather significant period of time, much like candidates for sainthood are in Catholicism.  In order to be a classic, I believe that a novel must do one of two things-it must either present such a clear cultural snapshot of a time and place that it comes to represent that time and place, or it must have themes that continue to resonate long after the actual time period in which it was written.  It must either be completely time-bound or have that indefinable quality of timelessness (or both, a la Jane Austen-completely captures Victorian England and presents timeless themes).

That said, the Catholic Church may take years to do it, but we all know Mother Theresa is going to be a saint.  I think that the most we can do as contemporary readers is determine the authors and novels we believe will be classics, and hopefully live long enough to see if we are right.  I think it is safe to say that if the critics get to pick, then I'm pretty sure the Jonathans (Franzen and Safran Foer) will be there.  This is easier done with children's books, since their generations are shorter.  Harry Potter has already been through a few generations of kids, and it continues to captivate them.  The Giver by Lois Lowry is another example, though that one is a crossover, since I know just as many adults as children who love that book.

As for adult novels, here are a few I hope will stand the test of time.  First, anything written by Margaret Atwood, but especially The Handmaid's Tale.  While I would love to envision a day when a woman's reproductive status does not define who she is, I'm gonna put my money on needing feminist writers like Atwood well into the future.  I also think that Toni Morrison's books will hold up to the passage of time.  While most people find Beloved her best work, I think that Paradise is a masterpiece of narrative structure.  Her fluid sense of time creates this wave of connection that really forces you as a reader to become engaged in a way that straightforward narratives do not.  A Thousand Splendid Suns is so powerful, and so moving, that if Hosseini's work is not remembered in 50 years it will be a tragedy.

Underlying this week's question, and most questions about English language fiction, is that the novels we read and find so powerful today only get into our hands because someone on an editorial staff in some publishing house decided that we get to read it.  While I think there is plenty of variety (and diversity) in the publishing world in general, I do notice a decided lack of authors of color or female authors in most of the discussions of "serious" contemporary authors.  I am not disputing the masterfulness of Franzen or Safran Foer or McCarthy or McEwan-I just think it makes sense to be mindful of the other voices not being heard as loudly.  Stay tuned for more on that topic later in the month, when I explain my theory of reading as social justice.


  1. You showcased wonderful books here!

    Here is my Literary Blog Hop post!

  2. I wonder why it is the serious books that win the prizes. Nothing humorous. And it is always books about war and violence and power and fighting. Nothing small.

    Random thoughts today from me.

  3. I'd agree that Margaret Atwood will still be read years from now, especially Handmaid's Tale.

  4. The Handmaid's Tale is a perfect choice... The messages and characters are so beautifully written, that I do believe that will become a classic.

  5. I loved your phrase "we all know that Mother Theresa is going to be a saint." I think that perhaps it is easier to think of authors that will become classic, rather than individual titles. Sort of how we read Eliot, Joyce and the Brontes...we also read Atwood and Morrison. There are certain authors that have that feeling that they'll stick around.

  6. I was thinking about how Harry Potter will stand up over the years. I read an article about how there has been a massive decline in the books in the past few years because the children who would have read them growing up have been surrounded by such a hogwarts culture that they become uninterested.

    i'm sure it will make a comeback once we stop fussing about everything JK Rowling, but it's interesting that it can already be going through a phase like this.

  7. How did I forget The Handmaid's Tale?!? I completely agree--this is a modern classic. Nice posting :)

  8. Haven't read the three adult novels you mentioned, but I agree that the Harry Potter books are almost destined to become classics.

  9. If it was down to Bloggers, I think Margaret Atwood would definitely make Classic status.I am in complete agreement concerning the listening of other voices & will be interested in your future post.

  10. I agree with you about Atwood, "the Jonathans" and Paradise. Oh, and Mother Theresa, too! This was a great post.

  11. I have read all the comments in your blog post. Most of them really agree on one common reason Literary Blog Hop-Contemporary Classic is still effective. The articles and the comments are very interactive. They give nice idea to each others.

  12. I read an article about how there has been a massive decline in the books in the past few years because the children who would have read them growing up have been surrounded by such a hogwarts culture that they become uninterested.


Penny for your thoughts...