Let me start by saying that I am not usually squeamish about dark and twisty stories. I have the stomach to read about things like incest, sexual assault, murder, etc...Not for me just the books that are full of sweetness and light-I like a book with a dark side. That said, I usually want there to be some sort of redemption involved, or justice being done, or something to resolve the story such that there is a larger message about this experience of being human we are all going through. Apparently, author Tawni O'Dell didn't get the same memo.
Back Roads is about as dark and twisty as a family drama can get. The description on Goodreads makes the book sound a bit like an overblown Lifetime movie. Harley is a 19 year old who suddenly finds himself looking after his three sisters after his mother is convicted of killing his abusive father. The pressures of working two jobs to make ends meet, and dealing with the emotional fall-out of their father's murder, takes a toll on Harley. Looking for an outlet, he begins a relationship with a mother of two from down the road. He becomes obsessed with her, and his obsession sets off a series of events that ultimately tears his family apart.
I remember when I wrote my review for the novel Push, which I actually really appreciate as a work of literary art. My one criticism of it was that I felt the author, Sapphire, had gone overboard on the tragedy, giving her main character every single problem that a person of her race, gender, and class might be expected to ever have. At least in that book, however, the problems were, if not resolved, improved throughout the course of the book, and it felt as though Sapphire was trying to highlight the specific issues of racism, sexism, classism, and gender violence that many people living in urban poverty experience. O'Dell's book also throws pretty much every family problem at her characters-incest, alcoholism, domestic violence, sexual assault, poverty-but in the end I was left wondering what the point of it all was. Almost none of the characters were that likable or relatable. They were all deeply flawed, which would be fine except that they never developed past them. I felt as though just about every character left the novel in exactly the same state as when the book began. And the serious issues presented about toxic family dynamics were sensationalized rather than examined critically.
Given all of that criticism, you might expect me to pan this book completely. But I still gave it three stars on Goodreads. Because despite my dissatisfaction with the ending, the story was engaging enough that I wanted to keep reading. Granted, I wanted to keep reading because I was sure that O'Dell was going to eventually offer a moment of redemption for at least one of the characters, but it was well written enough that I didn't want to give up on it. So if you don't mind dark and twisty for the sake of dark and twisty (and based on the number of true crime shows out there that do nothing but highlight dark and twisty there must be lots of you), then you would probably enjoy this book.