Like many young girls, I was given a copy of Little Women as a gift. Lousia May Alcott's perfect roman a clef about growing up in genteel poverty during the Civil War has been universally adored by generations of young readers, and despite the drastic social changes that have taken place in the intervening years, Jo March's struggle for independence and freedom from the conventions of society still resonates with many young women struggling to find their way in a complex and often confusing world.
So it was with great excitement that I picked up a copy of The Lost Summer of Lousia May Alcott by Kelly O'Connor McNees at a local discount store. I had read glowing reviews of the book on many of the blogs that I follow, and I anticipated feeling just as taken with the fictionalized account of one youthful summer as all of those bloggers had been. While many authors over the years have used primary historical documents to write fictionalized accounts of the lives of real people, this book seemed to promise some kind of new insight into a hidden chapter of Miss Alcott's life.
The Lost Summer recounts the events of one summer when Louisa was 20. She and her family go to stay in the house of a friend of their father's in Walpole, Massachusetts. Her father Bronson Alcott, was a philosopher who was friends with many of the important intellectuals of the mid 1800s-Emerson, Margaret Fuller, Thoreau, and others. Unfortunately for his family, he believed that working for money would sully his mind, and as a result the Alcott family lived off of the generosity of their friends and family, as well as whatever money the girls could bring in doing piecework or working as tutors and companions. Louisa meets Joseph Singer, a young man trying to manage his father's shop during the older man's long illness. There is an instant attraction between Joseph and Louisa, but he is already pledged to another girl, and she longs for the independence to write. Despite never wanting to marry, Louisa feels herself falling in love with Singer, bonding as they do over Walt Whitman's recently released Leaves of Grass.
Reading the author's note, it becomes obvious that there is actually no historical evidence that Louisa had a love affair as a young girl the year her family lived in Walpole. The entire affair is completely from the imagination of McNees. Which would have been fine, if the story of their love had been as gripping and tragic as some of those rhapsodizing bloggers seemed to find it. My problem with it was that it didn't seem realistic at all. They meet, make eyes at each other, read a few poems, and are suddenly consumed with an unquenchable love for each other. Maybe it's a function of my age, but I just didn't buy the "love at first sight" thing. Infatuation, yes. Physical desire, sure. But full-on, can't-live-without-you love? Sorry, I just didn't get it. As a result, while the book is very well written and I enjoyed McNees' descriptions of New England life in the 1850s, I can only say, "meh".
The Lost Summer of Louisa May Alcott
Saturday, September 24, 2011
Monday, September 12, 2011
So a couple of weeks ago I posted a review of Pawn of Prophecy, the first book in David Edding's Belgariad series. I talked about how it was a well-written fantasy series, with well-developed characters and well-paced action. All the typical archetypes are there-the sorcerer, the witch, the warriors, the rogue. It is an enjoyable journey in a sometimes dark fantastical world.
I just finished the second book in the series, that chronicles the further travels of Belgarath, Polgara, and Garion and their allies on their search for the orb. As for my review of said book-I can only say...
ditto.
I just finished the second book in the series, that chronicles the further travels of Belgarath, Polgara, and Garion and their allies on their search for the orb. As for my review of said book-I can only say...
ditto.
Sunday, September 04, 2011
Last year I reviewed Layton Green's first novel, The Summoner.
In it, Green introduces us to Dominic Grey, a former member of the US
diplomatic services security. While stationed in Zimbabwe, Grey is
drawn into the mysterious disappearance of a US diplomat, and its
connection to a ju-ju priest who seems to be able to do the impossible.
This year I was lucky enough to be asked to review his next book, The Egyptian.
When I reviewed Green's first book, I said that while I thought there were some pacing and exposition issues, I was excited to see where Grey's story went as the series continues. I was not disappointed. Green has taken Grey out of the Diplomatic Security Service-which I think allows for more flexibility in storylines over time-and has him working with Professor Viktor Radek investigating cults and mysterious, seemingly magical events around the globe. In The Egyptian, Radek and Grey are called in by a biomedical company to recover stolen research into a life extension product that could literally make humans almost immortal. But all is not what it seems-when Grey and an investigative reporter begin to uncover the location of the stolen research, they witness the slaughter of a team of scientists, which leads them to believe that the biotech company is somehow behind the violence. Drawn by their investigation to Egypt, they discover an ancient cult intent on controlling who is bestowed eternal life.
One of my favorite phrases for someone who seems to be feeling at the top of their game is "in the pocket". Green has found his groove with this series, and The Egyptian felt much more "in the pocket" that The Summoner. While there is less about Grey's back story in this book, there is enough to keep you interested in him as a character. The story moves from America to Europe to a lost oasis in the Sahara, making for a lot of globe-trotting action. The information about the immortality cult, and the science behind anti-aging, was presented in such a way that I felt like I learned a lot without being lectured at, and it was well-placed in the overall arc of the story. I am so glad that this series is shaping up the way it is...smart thrillers for people who like their action with some cognitive stimulation!
Thanks for Layton for giving me an advanced preview copy. You can get it in Kindle or Nook version from his website, www.laytongreen.com.
When I reviewed Green's first book, I said that while I thought there were some pacing and exposition issues, I was excited to see where Grey's story went as the series continues. I was not disappointed. Green has taken Grey out of the Diplomatic Security Service-which I think allows for more flexibility in storylines over time-and has him working with Professor Viktor Radek investigating cults and mysterious, seemingly magical events around the globe. In The Egyptian, Radek and Grey are called in by a biomedical company to recover stolen research into a life extension product that could literally make humans almost immortal. But all is not what it seems-when Grey and an investigative reporter begin to uncover the location of the stolen research, they witness the slaughter of a team of scientists, which leads them to believe that the biotech company is somehow behind the violence. Drawn by their investigation to Egypt, they discover an ancient cult intent on controlling who is bestowed eternal life.
One of my favorite phrases for someone who seems to be feeling at the top of their game is "in the pocket". Green has found his groove with this series, and The Egyptian felt much more "in the pocket" that The Summoner. While there is less about Grey's back story in this book, there is enough to keep you interested in him as a character. The story moves from America to Europe to a lost oasis in the Sahara, making for a lot of globe-trotting action. The information about the immortality cult, and the science behind anti-aging, was presented in such a way that I felt like I learned a lot without being lectured at, and it was well-placed in the overall arc of the story. I am so glad that this series is shaping up the way it is...smart thrillers for people who like their action with some cognitive stimulation!
Thanks for Layton for giving me an advanced preview copy. You can get it in Kindle or Nook version from his website, www.laytongreen.com.
Friday, August 26, 2011
One of the recurring motifs in high fantasy is the idea of the average villager actually being the lost prince of Somewhere, or the reincarnation of the great sorcerer Whoever. Unsuspecting mortals who are suddenly confronted with a destiny that is larger and more important than they realized. Maybe that is part of the reason that people enjoy high fantasy. For the average-Joe, who may feel powerless to change their own lives, the idea of secretly being the heir to the kingdom of Everywhere is pretty attractive.
David Eddings has created just such a scenario in his epic fantasy series, The Belgariad. The first book in the series is called Pawn of Prophecy. It introduces us to Garion, a young boy living with his Aunt Pol on a farm in Sendaria, a peaceful kingdom of the west. His world is narrow but comfortable, with Aunt Pol and the blacksmith Durnik to guide him. But Garion is haunted by visions of a dark rider who casts no shadow-a rider that no one else ever sees. One day, a storyteller named Mr. Wolf comes to the farm, and it becomes clear that he and Aunt Pol know each other. Mr. Wolf brings news-something important and powerful has been stolen, and Mr. Wolf and Aunt Pol (who are clearly more than they seem), leave the farm with Garion in tow. Durnik insists on accompanying the party to protect Aunt Pol. They meet up with two shady characters in the woods-Silk, a crafty, sly man, and Barak, an enormous warrior. Together they embark on a journey to find the lost artifact, and to stop the war that may be coming if they don't. Somehow Garion is connected to this artifact, but at an angsty 14 no one tells him anything.
This first installment does an excellent job of setting up the background for the future books. The reader is in the position of having information that Garion does not have as the result of a short prologue, which allows the reader to understand the strange events that surround Garion even when he can not. While the roles played by the main characters are pretty common for epic fantasy-the powerful sorcerer, the witch, the rogue, the warrior-there is at least decent character development, especially for Garion's character. Despite the fact that the characters are in fact hiding or following a trail of the artifact, there is enough action to provide some relief from the tedium of constant travel. The only real criticism I have is the same criticism I have for most high fantasy-apparently women in fantasy land will have to wait a little longer to be released from their oppression, as the only woman in the story so far that has any real power is Aunt Pol, who we discover is more than a simple cook. I'd like to see a good female warrior or two, or a queen who has the same power as her husband the king. But while we wait for the feminist movement to come to the various kingdoms of the Land of Fantasy, we can enjoy well-crafted stories like Pawn of Prophecy.
David Eddings has created just such a scenario in his epic fantasy series, The Belgariad. The first book in the series is called Pawn of Prophecy. It introduces us to Garion, a young boy living with his Aunt Pol on a farm in Sendaria, a peaceful kingdom of the west. His world is narrow but comfortable, with Aunt Pol and the blacksmith Durnik to guide him. But Garion is haunted by visions of a dark rider who casts no shadow-a rider that no one else ever sees. One day, a storyteller named Mr. Wolf comes to the farm, and it becomes clear that he and Aunt Pol know each other. Mr. Wolf brings news-something important and powerful has been stolen, and Mr. Wolf and Aunt Pol (who are clearly more than they seem), leave the farm with Garion in tow. Durnik insists on accompanying the party to protect Aunt Pol. They meet up with two shady characters in the woods-Silk, a crafty, sly man, and Barak, an enormous warrior. Together they embark on a journey to find the lost artifact, and to stop the war that may be coming if they don't. Somehow Garion is connected to this artifact, but at an angsty 14 no one tells him anything.
This first installment does an excellent job of setting up the background for the future books. The reader is in the position of having information that Garion does not have as the result of a short prologue, which allows the reader to understand the strange events that surround Garion even when he can not. While the roles played by the main characters are pretty common for epic fantasy-the powerful sorcerer, the witch, the rogue, the warrior-there is at least decent character development, especially for Garion's character. Despite the fact that the characters are in fact hiding or following a trail of the artifact, there is enough action to provide some relief from the tedium of constant travel. The only real criticism I have is the same criticism I have for most high fantasy-apparently women in fantasy land will have to wait a little longer to be released from their oppression, as the only woman in the story so far that has any real power is Aunt Pol, who we discover is more than a simple cook. I'd like to see a good female warrior or two, or a queen who has the same power as her husband the king. But while we wait for the feminist movement to come to the various kingdoms of the Land of Fantasy, we can enjoy well-crafted stories like Pawn of Prophecy.
Wednesday, August 24, 2011
Imagine while you are eating dinner tonight that every time you take a bite you can feel the emotions of the person who cooked it. This is the very unusual synesthesia that afflicts Rose, the main character of The Particular Sadness of Lemon Cake. OK, it's not exactly synesthesia, which refers to the neaurological condition where sensory input gets confused in the brain. Sounds suddenly have color, or tastes. Certain words are associated with smells...But Rose's ability to taste the emotions of the people who made her food was just one special ability in her family's DNA.
The Particular Sadness of Lemon Cake, by Aimee Bender, begins when Rose is a child. She comes home one day to a freshly-made chocolate lemon cake. When she takes a bite, she can suddenly feel how desperately lonely and unhappy her mother is. After an initial panic, she learns to eat as much food prepared by faceless factories-while she can tell where the ingredients came from and which factory manufactured it, she is not inundated with the feelings of strangers. But she can't avoid family dinners, and when her mother's food suddenly starts tasting of guilt, Rose knows that she is having an affair. At the same time, her brother Joe, who never really felt a part of the world, starts to disappear. Over the course of years, he is gone more frequently and for longer periods. Through it all, Rose deals with her relationship with her mother, her father, her friends, and George, her first crush and brother's best friend.
This book may be the most unique coming of age story that I have ever read. Rose's character is full of all the angst and uncertainty of any adolescent-I mean, aren't we already swimming in a storm of emotions as teens? Bender's writing is fluid and poetic, though she does have that annoying lack of quotation marks going against her. She manages to blend a rather surreal set of family quirks and strange events into a very realistic seeming story about a family who loves each other, but just can't seem to connect.
The Particular Sadness of Lemon Cake, by Aimee Bender, begins when Rose is a child. She comes home one day to a freshly-made chocolate lemon cake. When she takes a bite, she can suddenly feel how desperately lonely and unhappy her mother is. After an initial panic, she learns to eat as much food prepared by faceless factories-while she can tell where the ingredients came from and which factory manufactured it, she is not inundated with the feelings of strangers. But she can't avoid family dinners, and when her mother's food suddenly starts tasting of guilt, Rose knows that she is having an affair. At the same time, her brother Joe, who never really felt a part of the world, starts to disappear. Over the course of years, he is gone more frequently and for longer periods. Through it all, Rose deals with her relationship with her mother, her father, her friends, and George, her first crush and brother's best friend.
This book may be the most unique coming of age story that I have ever read. Rose's character is full of all the angst and uncertainty of any adolescent-I mean, aren't we already swimming in a storm of emotions as teens? Bender's writing is fluid and poetic, though she does have that annoying lack of quotation marks going against her. She manages to blend a rather surreal set of family quirks and strange events into a very realistic seeming story about a family who loves each other, but just can't seem to connect.
Saturday, August 13, 2011
As a science fiction fan, I have considered it a personal failing that I had never read any Kurt Vonnegut. As a pacifist, the fact that I had never read Slaughterhouse Five made that failing sting a little more. I wish I could say that reading this book was worth all of the years of self-recrimination. I wish I could say that I finished it. But the only thing I can say with any certainty is that I didn't get it.
I won't say that I don't understand why this book is considered a classic of science fiction specifically and literature generally. Vonnegut's writing is by turns funny, poignant, frightening, or evocative. Slaughterhouse Five tells the story of Billy Pilgrim, an accidental soldier who is captured by the Germans in 1945 and taken to Dresden. He is there during the Dresden bombings, when the Allies bombed the non-military city of Dresden and killed over 100,000 people. Vonnegut himself was a German prisoner of war who lived through the Dresden bombing and its aftermath. But this is not in fact the major event of Billy's life. Billy becomes "unstuck in time", moving through his own lifeline from prisoner to wealthy optometrist to alien zoo exhibit...yes, I said alien exhibit. Because the other major fact of Billy's life is that he was abducted by aliens on the night of this daughter's wedding.
OK, I only know the last part because I read the SparkNotes for the complete novel. Because I couldn't finish the book. Even with the excellent writing, I could not get into this story. It wasn't the writing, or the war, or the time travel, or the alien abduction. The only explanation I can come up with is that my brain just doesn't think the way that Vonnegut's does. Even though I already knew the destination theme-wise, I just couldn't follow where Vonnegut was leading. Despite my natural inclination to agree with the book's anti-war message, I wasn't sure how Billy Pilgrim traveling through time and being abducted by aliens was supposed to articulate that message. Of course, had I finished it, maybe all would become clear. And that's on me. I guess I'll just have to continue living my life as a science fiction fan who hasn't read Vonnegut. But this time I'll forgive myself.
I won't say that I don't understand why this book is considered a classic of science fiction specifically and literature generally. Vonnegut's writing is by turns funny, poignant, frightening, or evocative. Slaughterhouse Five tells the story of Billy Pilgrim, an accidental soldier who is captured by the Germans in 1945 and taken to Dresden. He is there during the Dresden bombings, when the Allies bombed the non-military city of Dresden and killed over 100,000 people. Vonnegut himself was a German prisoner of war who lived through the Dresden bombing and its aftermath. But this is not in fact the major event of Billy's life. Billy becomes "unstuck in time", moving through his own lifeline from prisoner to wealthy optometrist to alien zoo exhibit...yes, I said alien exhibit. Because the other major fact of Billy's life is that he was abducted by aliens on the night of this daughter's wedding.
OK, I only know the last part because I read the SparkNotes for the complete novel. Because I couldn't finish the book. Even with the excellent writing, I could not get into this story. It wasn't the writing, or the war, or the time travel, or the alien abduction. The only explanation I can come up with is that my brain just doesn't think the way that Vonnegut's does. Even though I already knew the destination theme-wise, I just couldn't follow where Vonnegut was leading. Despite my natural inclination to agree with the book's anti-war message, I wasn't sure how Billy Pilgrim traveling through time and being abducted by aliens was supposed to articulate that message. Of course, had I finished it, maybe all would become clear. And that's on me. I guess I'll just have to continue living my life as a science fiction fan who hasn't read Vonnegut. But this time I'll forgive myself.
Sunday, August 07, 2011
In Running With Scissors, Augusten Burroughs gave us a hilarious and horrifying look into his early life. When his parents divorced, Augusten's mother signed over guardianship of him to her psychotic psychiatrist. Refusing to go to school, he spent his days drinking or getting high with this foster sister, and being preyed upon by a 33 year old pedophile. It was a story like no other-hopefully because no one else has ever lived through that particular brand of hell.
Dry picks up the story of his life as an award winning copywriter at an ad agency and raging alcoholic. After a particularly disastrous business meeting, his company gives him an ultimatum-go to rehab or lose his job. He enters rehab determined to treat it as a spa vacation, only to be confronted pretty quickly with the strange world of group therapy and the 12 steps. He leaves rehab determined to stay sober, but the pressures of real life threaten his fragile sobriety. And this, this is a story I've heard before.
Granted, Dry is told with Burrough's usual wit. I admire his ability to laugh at himself, and unlike some recovery memoirs this one is not preachy or sentimental. But it also doesn't really have anything new to say on the subject of addiction. He was a drunk, for understandable reasons, but still a drunk. He nearly ruined his own (and a few other people's) life. He met some unusual characters in rehab, had difficulty re-entering the "real" (read: sober) world, etc...etc...If you are a fan of Augusten Burroughs, it is probably worth reading just so you can say you've read the "complete set", so to speak, but if you've never read his books before, start with Running with Scissors-much more compelling story.
Dry picks up the story of his life as an award winning copywriter at an ad agency and raging alcoholic. After a particularly disastrous business meeting, his company gives him an ultimatum-go to rehab or lose his job. He enters rehab determined to treat it as a spa vacation, only to be confronted pretty quickly with the strange world of group therapy and the 12 steps. He leaves rehab determined to stay sober, but the pressures of real life threaten his fragile sobriety. And this, this is a story I've heard before.
Granted, Dry is told with Burrough's usual wit. I admire his ability to laugh at himself, and unlike some recovery memoirs this one is not preachy or sentimental. But it also doesn't really have anything new to say on the subject of addiction. He was a drunk, for understandable reasons, but still a drunk. He nearly ruined his own (and a few other people's) life. He met some unusual characters in rehab, had difficulty re-entering the "real" (read: sober) world, etc...etc...If you are a fan of Augusten Burroughs, it is probably worth reading just so you can say you've read the "complete set", so to speak, but if you've never read his books before, start with Running with Scissors-much more compelling story.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



























